Loewenthal, K M, Goldblatt, V, Lubitsch, G, Gorton, T, Bicknell, H, Fellowes, D and Sowden, A (1997) The costs and benefits of boundary maintenance: Stress, religion and culture among Jews in Britain. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 32 (4).
Full text access: Open
This paper examined stress among two groups of orthodox Jews suggested to differ in the strength of the boundary of their religious group. Comparisons were made between the two groups, and with urban and rural groups studied by other researchers. Proportions of boundary-maintenance events (events whose threat had been caused or exacerbated by Jewishness) and of severe events, and proportions and rates of regular, irregular and disruptive events were examined. Boundary-maintenance events were higher among the more religiously orthodox affiliated group, and among whom religious observance was indeed reported to be higher. It was suggested that conditions of higher boundary maintenance would be associated with higher rates and proportions of regular events and with lower rates and proportions of irregular and disruptive events. Generally, the analyses supported this expectation. Boundary-maintenance events themselves were somewhat less severe, though not less likely to be irregular or disruptive than other events. Depression was shown to be unrelated to boundary-maintenance events and (surprisingly) unrelated to contextual threat when the effects of irregularity-disruption were controlled. Depression was, however, strongly related to irregular and disruptive events. The results are compared with those of related work, and suggest that the general lowering effect of affiliation to a religious group may be partly explained by the effects of boundary maintenance, which involves stress, but of a less depressogenic kind than the disruptive stress associated with conditions of low/no boundary maintenance. The findings have implications for understanding the relations between culture and mental disorder
This is a Published version This version's date is: 05/1997 This item is peer reviewed
https://repository.royalholloway.ac.uk/items/5e1e523b-ac63-7df1-66f4-307e422e10f1/1/
Deposited by () on 23-Dec-2009 in Royal Holloway Research Online.Last modified on 23-Dec-2009
Brown GW, Harris TO (1978) The Social Origins of Depression. Tavistock Press, London. Brown GW, Harris TO (eds) (1989) Life Events and Illness. Unwin Hyman, London. Brown GW, Harris TO, Hepworth C (1993) Loss, humiliation and entrapment among women developing depression: a patient and non-patient comparison. Psychol Med 25:7-21. Brown GW, Prudo R (1981) Psychiatric disorder in a rural and in an urban population: 1. Aetiology of depression. Psychol Med 11:581-599. Douglas M (1966) Purity and Danger. Routledge & Kegan Paul, London Durkheim E (1933) The Division of Labour in Society. (Trans G Simpson) MacMillan, New York. Durkheim E (1951) Suicide. (Trans JJ Spaulding, G.Simpson) Free Press, Glencoe, Illinois. English HB, English AC (1958) A Comprehensive Dictionary of Psychological and Psychoanalytical Terms. Longmans, New York. Green & Co. Gaminde I, Uria M, Padro D, Querejeta I, Ozamiz A (1993) Depression in three populations in the Basque country - a comparison with Britain. Soc Psychiat Psychiat Epidemiol 28:243-251. Jelen TG (1990) Ageing and boundary maintenance among American Evangelicals. Rev Rel Res 31:268-279. Katzir Y (1982) Preservation of Jewish ethnic identity in Yemen - segregation and integration as boundary maintenance mechanisms. Comp Studs Soc Hist 264-279. Kosmin BA, Levy C (1983) Jewish Identity in an Anglo-Jewish Community. Research Unit Board of Deputies of British Jews, London. Levi-Strauss C (1963) Structural Anthropology. (Trans C Jacobson, BG Schoepf) Basic Books, New York. Loewenthal KM (1995) Religion and Mental Health. Chapman & Hall, London. Loewenthal KM, Goldblatt V, Amos V, Mullarkey S. (1993) Some correlates of distress in Anglo-Jewish women. In L Brown (ed) Religion, Personality and Mental Health. Springer-Verlag, New York. Loewenthal K, Goldblatt V, Gorton T, Lubitsch G, Bicknell H, Fellowes D, Sowden A (1995) Gender and depression in Anglo-Jewry. Psychol Med 25:1051-1063. Lora A, Fava E (1992) Provoking agents, vulnerability factors and depression in an Italian setting: A replication of Brown and Harris's model. J Aff Disord 24:227-235. Martin B (1981) A Sociology of Contemporary Cultural Change. Blackwell, Oxford. Pescosolido B, Georgiana S (1989) Durkheim, suicide and religion. Am Soc Rev 54:33-48. Prudo R, Harris T, Brown GW (1984) Psychiatric disorder in a rural and in an urban population: 3. Social integration and the morphology of affective disorder. Psychol Med 14:327-345. Sivin N (1991) Science, religion and boundary maintenance. Contemp Soc 20:526-530. Stack S (1992) Religiosity, depression and suicide. In J Schumaker (ed) Religion and Mental Health. Oxford University Press, Oxford. Turner V (1969) The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure. Routledge & Kegan Paul, London. Waterman S, Kosmin BA (1986) British Jewry in the Eighties. Research Unit Board of Deputies of British Jews, London. West R (1991) Computing for psychologists. Harwood Academic Publishers, Chur. Wing JK, Cooper JE, Sartorius N (1974) The Measurement and Classification of Psychiatric Symptoms. Cambridge University Press, London. Worsley P (1970) Introducing Sociology. Penguin, Harmondsworth, Middlesex. Table 1. Comparison of Strictly and Traditionally-Orthodox subjects with respect to reported religious observance (all means are on a scale from 1=fully observed to 4=never observed).