A study in empirical knowledge: The preconditions and structure of measurement

Harvey, Maurice Edward Matheson

(1982)

Harvey, Maurice Edward Matheson (1982) A study in empirical knowledge: The preconditions and structure of measurement.

Our Full Text Deposits

Full text access: Open

10098438.pdf - 39.29 MB

Abstract

This is an epistemological study, in which measure ment is taken as a paradigm of perceptual recognition---a notion in which perception is joined with judgment as a factor in understanding. Hence it has proved necessary to give an analysis of such recognition in general, with metric contexts as a special case. This has been done in terms of a very weak fundamental form of 'theory', as a form of basic comprehension, in which language (as part of the theories analysed) is not essentially involved, but treated as a special development.

One type of theory is given thorough formal analysis: those 'recognitive theories' whose elements are taken, in the theory itself, to be recognized directly from perception, or extrapolated as in principle recognizable. Another type consists of 'substantive theories', seen as constructed to provide deeper understanding of the reality underlying recognized structures, but essentially involving elements not taken to be recognizable: this type receivesonly informal treatment, in terms of its associations with the first (especially in measurement).

Special consideration is (unusually) given to attention and neglect,not in psychological terms, but as theory-guided selection from total experience. Neglect is seen not merely as negation of attention, but often a positive strategy (in measurement, strictly determined).

Part I introduces the basic concepts, distinguishing the general approach from other relevant traditionsfoundational studies in measurement (Suppes et al.); linguistic analysis; some epistemologies (e.g., Goodman); philosophy of science. Part II sets up the formal analysis. Part III applies this analysis to contexts of measurement, with examples (only distance is fully treated others only in synopsis). Probability assessment is analysed as distinct from measurement. Part IV examines consequences for wider philosophical questions: language-based problems of knowledge and meaning; Wittgenstein's 'private language': and theory-based considerations of ontology; identity; truth, falsity and error; and observation in science.

Information about this Version

This is a Accepted version
This version's date is: 1982
This item is not peer reviewed

Link to this Version

https://repository.royalholloway.ac.uk/items/b9e433d7-c8ee-40a9-b2ab-9e9db7ceb2b8/1/

Item TypeThesis (Doctoral)
TitleA study in empirical knowledge: The preconditions and structure of measurement
AuthorsHarvey, Maurice Edward Matheson
Uncontrolled KeywordsEpistemology; Philosophy; Philosophy, Religion And Theology; Philosophy, Religion And Theology; A; Empirical; Empirical Knowledge; Empirical Knowledge; Knowledge; Measurement; Preconditions; Structure; Study
DepartmentsDepartment of Philosophy

Identifiers

ISBN978-1-339-62498-3

Deposited by () on 01-Feb-2017 in Royal Holloway Research Online.Last modified on 01-Feb-2017

Notes

Digitised in partnership with ProQuest, 2015-2016. Institution: University of London, Bedford College (United Kingdom).


Details